esstac vs S&J Hardware vs soe nylon shell carriers

[slikrickabn]

You guys out there using these brands, which do you feel the best, as far as ease of use and longevity of the elastic in them? I'm going to take a hard 4 shell carrier off my 870 and upgrade to this style, but wonder which is the best quality, I'm going to use them with a velcro chest carrier to hold three more of them, for a total of 4 available for spare ammo. Any feedback is appreciated...

slik

[NowR2run]

ESSTAC is very good but you have too buy your own 3M or equivalent velcro glue separate, DON'T KNOW WHY ?

[NowR2run]

SPANKER ELITE is also good but also have too buy your own velcro for it to stick too receiver.

[Appy1965]

Esstac and SOE both are known for durability and strong elasticity. Esstac is especially praised for ease of use, while SOE is a bit tougher and more rugged.